Showing posts with label intel ops. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intel ops. Show all posts

Friday, February 24, 2012

Has NYPD Gone Too Far In Surveillance Efforts Looking For Islamic Extremists?

Following the intel failures that led to the US government being unprepared for the 9/11 attacks, the NYPD vastly expanded its intel efforts, including establishing outposts in foreign countries to bring in intel directly from those foreign countries instead of relying solely on the FBI or CIA.

Those surveillance efforts include looking for Muslim extremists in the New York City metro area - including in New Jersey. While the NYPD can claim that they've thwarted numerous plots involving Islamic terrorists since 9/11, there have been several notable failures, including the Times Square bomber, Faisal Shazad. In that case, police didn't know of the plot to attack Times Square with a bomb planted in a SUV. Police learned of the incident after a local vendor alerted police to the smoking vehicle and it was only after conducting standard investigation techniques that Shazad was arrested.

As a result of the revelations about the scope of the surveillance, Muslim groups across the region are speaking out against the NYPD spying efforts, noting that it's a potential civil rights violation. They have a point, and while then-New Jersey Governor Richard Codey was informed of the spying efforts in places like Newark and elsewhere in the state, it doesn't mean that there was sufficient oversight.

Following the NYPD's illegal surveillance of radical groups during the 1970s, the NYPD entered into an agreement in 1985 called Handschu that required oversight of surveillance operations.
The Handschu agreement, as it is often referred to, was established in 1985 after decades of covert NYPD infiltration of activist groups including the New York City chapter of the Black Panthers. It also kept tabs on citizens who had done nothing more than sign a petition to end the Vietnam war, reporting their political positions to potential employers.

The element of the NYPD responsible for this surveillance went through a number of names, including the Italian squad, the black hand squad, and the bureau of special services. Today it is known as the intelligence division.

Handschu restricted the department's powers to monitor political groups, stipulating that police needed information indicating that a crime was being committed in order to investigate political activity. The rules remained in place for over 15 years.

In 2002 the NYPD, under the guidance of former CIA officer Cohen, lobbied to have Handschu's restrictions significantly loosened, following the September 11 attacks of the previous year. The department argued that it could not effectively fight terrorism with the rules in place.

The NYPD largely got what it wanted in 2003, when significant modifications were made to the agreement.

Civil rights attorney Jethro Eisentstein, who is involved in a class action lawsuit against the NYPD in relation to Handschu, says what remains of the agreement is vitally important to the latest revelations concerning the NYPD's surveillance of Muslim communities.
Specifically, Handschu required that surveillance operations must secure a warrant from a three-person panel comprised of two police commissioners and a mayor-appointed civilian. That was modified in 2003 when the panel was reduced to a single person.

It's the reduction of the panel to a single person that opens the door to mischief and it's time to restore a 3-person panel. That wont necessarily eliminate all warrants along these lines, but introduces a level of oversight lacking when you have a single person who is intent upon investigations that might lead to violations of civil rights (to say nothing of accusations of malfeasance).

Mayor Bloomberg and Commissioner Ray Kelly are defending the actions, and Bloomberg calls critics naive. Sorry, but that doesn't quite cut it. While there are indeed serious concerns about terror groups operating in the NYC metro area based on past history (both the 9/11 attackers and the 1993 WTC bombers had ties to the metro area), wholesale spying on an entire community is overbroad. It also reduces the level of trust between the Muslim community that would be willing to work with law enforcement to root out extremists in their midst and actually makes it more difficult to track down those who might be plotting attacks down the line.

Thursday, May 27, 2010

Terror Attack Attempts Against US At All Time High

The number of attempted terror attacks against the US are at an all time high.
Just weeks after the failed car bombing of New York's Times Square, the Department of Homeland Security says "the number and pace of attempted attacks against the United States over the past nine months have surpassed the number of attempts during any other previous one-year period."

That grim assessment is contained in an unclassified DHS intelligence memo prepared for various law enforcement groups, which says terror groups are expected to try attacks inside the United States with "increased frequency."

CNN obtained a copy of the document, dated May 21, which goes on to warn, "we have to operate under the premise that other operatives are in the country and could advance plotting with little or no warning."

The intelligence note says recent attempted terror attacks have used operatives and tactics which made the plots hard to detect.

The document specifically mentions the cases of Afghan national Najibullah Zazi, who pleaded guilty in February to plotting attacks on New York's subways, and Times Square bombing suspect Faisal Shahzad, a Pakistani-American.

The intelligence report says both men spent significant time in the United States and were familiar with their alleged targets. Furthermore, the plots involved materials that can be commonly purchased in America without causing suspicion.

The document also says Shahzad and Zazi had short periods of training overseas "compared to lengthier training cycles for earlier operations, reducing our ability to detect their activities."
Many of these plots involve US citizens or legal immigrants who went overseas to receive terror training in places like Pakistan or Yemen and/or received funding from overseas but may or may not have been part of an official terror group like al Qaeda. Rather, they are lone wolf or affiliated terrorists who do not have direct ties to terror groups.

This makes the intel operations to detect and thwart such attacks all the more difficult. In the case of Shahzad, it was only a bomb that failed to properly detonate that prevented the loss of life. The short training cycles means that the terrorists might not have the training necessary to complete their missions, but it makes detection even more difficult.

It also points to the possibility of exposing the terror training camps because more people are flowing through in shorter time, but it also means that tracking those individuals becomes more difficult.

National security relies on gathering intel and thwarting attacks before they reach US shores. That means carrying out clandestine operations to track and eliminate terror training camps and the terror masters in the Middle East and places like Pakistan - the very sort of operation approved by Gen. David Petraeus (and published by the NY Times), which undermines the ability of such clandestine operations to be successful.

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

When Is A Secret Policy Not A Secret? When the NY Times Deems It So

When is a secret policy not a secret? When it gets published in the NYT. The more things change, the more they stay the same and it doesn't matter what Administration we're talking about.

The Obama Administration and Gen. Petraeus had ordered a broad expansion of clandestine military activity in an effort to disrupt militant groups or counter threats in Iran, Saudi Arabia, Somalia and other countries in the region, according to defense officials and military documents.
The secret directive, signed in September by Gen. David H. Petraeus, authorizes the sending of American Special Operations troops to both friendly and hostile nations in the Middle East, Central Asia and the Horn of Africa to gather intelligence and build ties with local forces. Officials said the order also permits reconnaissance that could pave the way for possible military strikes in Iran if tensions over its nuclear ambitions escalate.

While the Bush administration had approved some clandestine military activities far from designated war zones, the new order is intended to make such efforts more systematic and long term, officials said. Its goals are to build networks that could “penetrate, disrupt, defeat or destroy” Al Qaeda and other militant groups, as well as to “prepare the environment” for future attacks by American or local military forces, the document said. The order, however, does not appear to authorize offensive strikes in any specific countries.

In broadening its secret activities, the United States military has also sought in recent years to break its dependence on the Central Intelligence Agency and other spy agencies for information in countries without a significant American troop presence.

General Petraeus’s order is meant for small teams of American troops to fill intelligence gaps about terror organizations and other threats in the Middle East and beyond, especially emerging groups plotting attacks against the United States.
Note the word clandestine. That means covert, secret, and otherwise not to be broadcast to the general public.

So, what does the Times do? You got it. They published it, based on their sources.

Once again, the Times thinks that its job is to determine the national security policy of the US and that they are the final arbiter of what is necessarily secret and what isn't. Are they putting US troops and US national security at risk? I believe that they are, and they are increasing the risks for blowback.

Yet, there is some good news in all this. I will say that this does give me a better feeling about the Administration's counter-terror operations that they were letting the DoD take on covert ops in the Middle East, although my confidence in the Administration's actual knowledge of ME policy - particularly the operation of terror groups like Hizbullah, Hamas, and the ME peace process leave me scratching my head as if they've never heard of Bernard Lewis, or read anything other than the diplomatic releases that engage in pseudoreality on a regular basis. After all, this is the same Administration that thinks that they can reach out to moderates in Hizbullah, and that Hamas will accept a peace deal with Israel even though that terror group has nothing but the eradication of Israel on its mind.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Michael Furlong's War

The New York Times is reporting that investigations are moving forward on whether a Defense Department official, Michael Furlong, operated his own rogue paramilitary/intel unit in Afghanistan and Pakistan to track down and kill al Qaeda and Taliban units without proper authorizations from higher in the chain of command.
The official, Michael D. Furlong, hired contractors from private security companies that employed former C.I.A. and Special Forces operatives. The contractors, in turn, gathered intelligence on the whereabouts of suspected militants and the location of insurgent camps, and the information was then sent to military units and intelligence officials for possible lethal action in Afghanistan and Pakistan, the officials said.

While it has been widely reported that the C.I.A. and the military are attacking operatives of Al Qaeda and others through unmanned, remote-controlled drone strikes, some American officials say they became troubled that Mr. Furlong seemed to be running an off-the-books spy operation. The officials say they are not sure who condoned and supervised his work.

It is generally considered illegal for the military to hire contractors to act as covert spies. Officials said Mr. Furlong’s secret network might have been improperly financed by diverting money from a program designed to merely gather information about the region.

Moreover, in Pakistan, where Qaeda and Taliban leaders are believed to be hiding, the secret use of private contractors may be seen as an attempt to get around the Pakistani government’s prohibition of American military personnel’s operating in the country.

Officials say Mr. Furlong’s operation seems to have been shut down, and he is now is the subject of a criminal investigation by the Defense Department for a number of possible offenses, including contract fraud.
It isn't clear when Furlong began these operations, but they accelerated in pace during the summer of 2009, which caught the attention of investigators. The AP reports that the Penatagon put Furlong in charge of a program to use private companies to gather information about Afghanistan's political and tribal culture.
Part of the original $22 million contract that Furlong was directing remains intact, the official told the AP, because it provides the funding for nine workers involved in information-gathering, translation and similar work. Those workers are employed by International Media Ventures with offices in Florida, Texas and elsewhere.

Nine employees from International Media Ventures were hired by the U.S. military to serve as information analysts and in other administrative jobs at the International Security Assistance Force headquarters operations center in Kabul, said Maj. Steven Cole, a spokesman for the international military coalition in Afghanistan.
No one is clear whether he was authorized to run this operation, and it isn't clear whether the information he gathered was actually used by the military or CIA to engage terrorists although sources do claim that the intel was acted upon. Intel gathered by these private contractors appears to have found its way into Defense Department and CIA hands. A contractor working for Furlong claims that millions of dollars that were supposed to go to the Web site run by Eason Jordan was redirected by Mr. Furlong toward intelligence gathering for the purpose of attacking militants, in violation of his contractual obligations and orders.

In some respects, this reads like Charlie Wilson's war.

If Furlong operated outside the chain of command and exceeded his authority, then these investigations should find him in violation of the applicable law. The problem becomes whether he was authorized to do so (and who issued the authorizations) and whether the program was successful or not - and those in the Times article seems to lean towards it being not successful. If it was successful, then outing the program could lead to problems down the road and ends a potentially successful intel operation.

The Defense Department can't account for about $15 million provided Furlong for his operations.

Friday, January 22, 2010

Ominous Warnings About Al Qaeda's Latest Intentions

The British government has raised their terror alert level.
The threat level was raised from "substantial" — where it had stood since July to indicate a strong possibility of a terrorist attack — to "severe," meaning such an attack is considered highly likely.

In making the announcement, Home Secretary Alan Johnson said the raised security level means that Britain is heightening its vigilance. But he stressed that there was no intelligence suggesting an attack is imminent.

"The highest security alert is `critical,' and that means an attack is imminent, and we are not at that level," he said on British television.

Johnson declined to say what intelligence the change was based on, or whether the move was related to the failed Christmas bombing attempt, when U.S. authorities say a young Nigerian named Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab tried to detonate a bomb hidden in his underwear during a flight from Amsterdam to Detroit. Abdulmutallab, who allegedly had links to extremists based in Yemen, had studied as a university student in London.
Officials aren't saying specifically what caused them to increase the level, but it likely has to do with intel coming in regarding al Qaeda, including that which underwear bombing suspect Umar Farouk Abdul Mutallab had told investigators. ABC News claims that Mutallab has provided information about who else was at the terror training camps he attended, and that al Qaeda may be trying to get female suicide bombers onto flights in an attempt to thwart profiling measures.
One official said at least two of them are believed to be connected to al Qaeda in Yemen, and may have a non-Arab appearance and be traveling on Western passports.

The threat was described as "current" but not imminent, said the official.

"They have trained women," said former White House counterterrorism official Richard Clarke, an ABC News consultant.
Al Qaeda has always sought out the spectacular terror attack, and taking down another airplane would be a coup on their part. While they could just as easily go after the train system in Europe or subways here in the US with deadly consequences, they're still fixated on taking down airlines. We have to hope that we can gather sufficient intel, put it in the hands of those who can act on it in a timely fashion, and prevent these terrorists from carrying out their deadly plans.

Monday, January 04, 2010

Double Agent Responsible For New Year's Eve Bombing Killing 7 CIA Agents

A double agent was responsible for the suicide bombing that killed seven CIA agents and his Jordanian intel agency handler. He had been captured by the Jordanians and they believed he had been turned, but it now shows that they underestimated Balawi's capacity for evil.
The suicide bombing on a CIA base in Afghanistan last week was carried out by a Jordanian doctor who was an al-Qaida double agent, Western intelligence officials told NBC News.

Initial reports said that the attack, which killed seven CIA officers, was carried out by a member of the Afghan National Army.

According to Western intelligence officials, the perpetrator was Humam Khalil Abu-Mulal al-Balawi, 36, an al-Qaida sympathizer from the town of Zarqa, which is also the hometown of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the Jordanian militant Islamist responsible for several devastating attacks in Iraq.

Al-Balawi was arrested by Jordanian intelligence more than a year ago. However, the Jordanians believed that al-Balawi had been successfully reformed and brought over to the American and Jordanian side, setting him up as an agent and sending him off to Afghanistan and Pakistan to infiltrate al-Qaida.

His specific mission, according to officials, was to find and meet Ayman al Zawahiri, al-Qaida’s No. 2, also a physician.

However, the Al-Jazeera Web site quoted a Taliban spokesman who said al-Balawi misled Jordanian and U.S. intelligence services for a year. The spokesman, Al-Hajj Ya'qub, promised to release a video confirming his account of the attack.
The Jordanian intel officer happens to be a relative to Jordan's King Abdullah and the Jordanians responded to his death with a state funeral.
Jordan's official news agency, Petra, said bin Zeid was killed "on Wednesday evening as a martyr while performing the sacred duty of the Jordanian forces in Afghanistan" and provided no further details about his death. Local news reports quoted family members as saying bin Zeid had been in Afghanistan for 20 days and had been scheduled to travel home on the day of the bombing.

His coffin's arrival in Amman on Saturday was handled with unusual pomp, with Jordan's King Abdullah II and his wife, Rania, personally presiding over a funeral and burial in a military cemetery.

Current and former U.S. intelligence officials said the special relationship with Jordan dates back at least three decades and has recently progressed to the point that the CIA liaison officer in Amman enjoys full, unescorted access to the GID's fortress-like headquarters. The close ties helped disrupt several known terrorist plots, including the thwarted 2000 "millennium" conspiracy to attack tourists at hotels and other sites. Jordanians also provided U.S. officials with communications intercepts in summer 2001 that warned of terrorist plans to carry out a major attack on the United States.
Jordan has been working closely with the US to thwart al Qaeda attacks, and that has also meant that al Qaeda has put Jordan in the crosshairs, including a 2005 bombing at an Amman hotel that killed more than 50.

I fear we may see more of these kinds of attacks as the US and other intel services attempt to cultivate agents and associations with those with access to al Qaeda's hierarchy and some of them turn out to be double agents. It puts the CIA and other intel agencies at risk, not only with dubious intel, but puts their agents on the front lines at risk of suicide bombings and other attacks.

It also shows the difficulties in trying to infiltrate these terror organizations, and the lengths to which we and our allies have gone to make the attempt.

Saturday, December 15, 2007

Democrats Cave On FISA and War Funding... Again

Once again, Congressional Democrats simply can't muster the votes or the backbone to stand up for the principles they claim to have. Their most vocal members have wanted to stop the funding of the war.

They couldn't do that.

They tried to radically amend FISA.

They couldn't do that either.

No, what happened is that the lame duck president and a GOP minority were able to not only hold the line, but get timetables stripped from the war funding measures. The Administration got what it wanted, albeit months late.
The Democratic-led Congress authorized more Iraq war spending on Friday, sending President Bush a defense bill requiring no change in strategy after failing again to impose a timetable for U.S. troop withdrawals.

The defense policy bill, approved 90-3 by the Senate, also expanded the size of the U.S. Army and set conditions on the Bush administration’s plan to build a missile defense system in Europe.

The measure already had passed the House and now goes to Bush, who is expected to sign it into law. It authorizes Pentagon programs expected to cost $506.9 billion during fiscal 2008, which began in October.

The bill authorized another $189.4 billion for the Iraq and Afghan wars, for which Congress has already approved some $600 billion. But it does not deliver the new money. That is done by appropriations legislation at the center of a big dispute on Capitol Hill.
The Senate voted 90-3 to fund the war effort and the military budget. Voting against? Byrd, Feingold, and Saunders.

Those unable to muster the backbone to vote on the measure: presidential candidates Biden (D-DE), Clinton (D-NY), Dodd (D-CT), McCain (R-AZ), and Obama (D-IL). Running for president apparently means missing important votes that might have to be explained to voters before the general election. Boxer (D-CA) and Inouye (D-HI) also didn't vote.

It also looks like Congress is going to cave to the Administration on FISA.

Congress enjoys playing games with the war funding and national security matters, which helps explain why no one actually approves of the job Congress is doing. The transparent leftist agenda by the Democrats has soured most everyone on Congress and the leadership by Pelosi and Reid - leftist Democrats don't like the job they're doing because they can't follow through on their promises, and everyone else doesn't like the job they're doing because they are trying to follow through on those same promises.

And what makes this especially interesting is that it comes in the form of a Friday Night news dump. The Democrats had to bury this information so that their base didn't go completely nuts (again). Indeed, far from running headlines, the New York Times has only a minor link to it on their front page - precisely because passing the budget with no strings attached is yet another stinging defeat for the Democrats but a victory for the Administration and those who want to see the war effort through to completion and victory.

Others blogging: Michelle Malkin, Gateway Pundit, Blue Star Chronicles.

Friday, December 14, 2007

Curious Congressional Priorities

Congress is in the process of passing long overdue appropriations budgets. This item, however, struck me as most curious.
The bill, a House-Senate compromise to authorize intelligence operations in 2008, also blocks spending 70 percent of the intelligence budget until the House and Senate intelligence committees are briefed on Israel's Sept. 6 air strike on an alleged nuclear site in Syria. (Reuters)
Congress is going to withhold the overwhelming majority of the intel budget until the intel committees are briefed on the Israeli raid from September 6?

Are you kidding me?

We're in a war, and Congress is playing games with the intel budget again because they want a briefing on what Israel did September 6. I'm just as curious as everyone else following the September 6 raid, but to withhold a critical budget item because Congress wants to hear what US intel agencies know about the raid is the height of folly.

Congress, but holding the funds, would limit intel activities that are crucial and necessary to maintaining national security going forward because they want information on a raid that took place this past September by one of our allies against Syria, which harbors terrorist groups including Hizbullah, and whose regime undermines the territorial and political integrity of Lebanon.

Where is the sense in this?

Also covering this is Bryan at Hot Air, who provides me with the HT. Thanks.

UPDATE:
This provision was part of a larger bill that would ban waterboarding. It's within Congress's right to ban that procedure, but they (and us) will have to live with the repercussions.

Monday, August 06, 2007

FISA Finagling

Speaker Nancy Pelosi doesn't like the fact that Congress overwhelmingly passed President Bush's FISA revision, so she's gone out of her way to instruct the House Intel Chairs to introduce legislation that would amend and gut the just passed and signed legislation. From Speaker Pelosi's newsroom:
Pelosi Requests Conyers and Reyes Offer Legislation to Amend FISA ‘As Soon as Possible’

"Many provisions of this legislation are unacceptable, and, although the bill has a six month sunset clause, I do not believe the American people will want to wait that long before corrective action is taken."
08/04/2007
The law went beyond simply amending certain provisions of FISA, and expands the government's ability to listen in on communications entering or leaving the US.

President Bush signed the legislation into law yesterday. It has a six-month sunset provision, which means that Congress will be able to take up any changes prior to that time and would provide the ability to see whether the provisions work as intended. Pelosi isn't about to wait that long. She'd rather gut and limit the ability to detect terrorist communiques than to see whether such efforts actually work.

The text of the legislation in question is here.

Monday, July 23, 2007

The Weakest Link

Air security is only as good as its weakest link. And watching how Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport handles its air security and screening during the overnight hours, one can only say that security is asleep at the switch.
Security checkpoints are just part of travel these days. They're supposed to keep us safe, so we use them - but not all of us and not all the time.

We've discovered a 4.5 hour time frame each night when virtually anything can be brought into the secure side of Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport. There's no metal detector, no X-ray machine, and it's apparently not a problem.

Afraid to show her face, one long time Sky Harbor employee talks about the security most people don't see.

Lisa Fletcher: "You're telling me Sky Harbor's not safe?"

Employee: "I'm telling you Sky Harbor's not safe and hasn't been for a long time."

It's what we discovered in the middle of the night - TSA agents going away, and security guards taking over. It's 4.5 hours - every night - when an employee badge becomes an all-access pass.

Night after night, our hidden cameras captured what security experts tell us is a disaster waiting to happen.

The X-ray machines were off, the metal detectors were closed, and bags with unknown contents were carried to the secure side of the airport where the planes are.

We watched as a security guard let people with purses, coolers and suitcases
walk right through - bags unchecked.
When you have passengers and other individuals who are able to gain access to the secured areas beyond the inactive x-ray scanners and screening section without inspection of baggage, one wonders how exactly can this be called security?

What makes it all the more galling is that the TSA supposedly has signed off on this arrangement despite TSA regulations that require baggage checks at airports 24/7/365.

How many other airports around the country have substandard baggage checks during the overnight hours and does anyone at the TSA actually care? If someone is able to get into the system, they're able to fly around the country and the world and no one would be any the wiser that someone was able to bring contraband or worse aboard.

UPDATE:
It's those kinds of things that keeps VP Cheney up all night, and Newsweek points to a new biography of the Vice President and spins some of this worry as a negative - the gloomy demeanor of the man. The VP has long worried about additional terrorist attacks and continuity of government should an attack decapitate the chain of command, and it is actually good to see that someone was taking an interest in such a dire and unspoken concern.

Yet, the Newsweek piece is also informative in that the intel that was coming into the WH was so much garbage. There was no way to process and weed out reports:
Most Americans have not quite grasped how imminent and overwhelming the danger seemed to be, at least to those reading the incoming intelligence. Under pressure to produce something—anything—about terrorist planning, the CIA and FBI flooded the White House with raw intelligence, much of it dubious or just wrong, but terrifying in its totality. At one point, security officials believed that the home belonging to Elizabeth Cheney, the veep's daughter, had been hit by an anthrax attack. Elizabeth had to call her nanny to get her to take the kids to "the mall," as she put it—so they could be tested for exposure.

In a revealing interview, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice (at the time Bush's national-security adviser), told Hayes, "[Cheney] read every intelligence report. I mean every intelligence report no matter how minor. And I was feeling kind of driven crazy by not knowing how to—at that time we didn't really have a good system for sorting what was reliable and what wasn't. I mean, we were just getting raw reporting of everything that was coming in, you know. So I remember thinking that he had an extraordinary memory ... for all of these things."
How exactly could anyone make a rational decision when the intel on which they had to act was faulty, inaccurate, and contradictory. Hindsight may prove the intel to be faulty, but when one looks at the volumn of reports, one had to err on the side of caution and do what was best for the nation's national security. It's an ongoing problem, and building in new layers of bureaucracy do little to improve intel gathering and analysis.

UPDATE:
The TSA has taken action as a result of being embarrassed by the major failings to screen passengers and personnel 24/7 at Sky Harbor.
As a result of an ABC15 Investigation, Transportation Security Administration administrator Kip Hawley has determined Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport is violating TSA policy which requires all workers to be screened at security checkpoints.

The TSA has reportedly placed the Federal Security Director at Sky Harbor on administrative leave.

The TSA also says it will resume 24-hour screening tonight at all airport security checkpoints.
A follow up question should be whether other airports engaged in similar behavior. I suspect it was not alone.

Thursday, July 12, 2007

The Jihad Blotter

So, what is one supposed to make of the report that al Qaeda has rebuilt its capabilities to a level not seen since before 9/11? Well, consider first that this information was published as a result of a leak of classified information to a journalist. Is this report accurate and on the mark? The intelligence agencies haven't exactly had a sterling record on predicting what would happen on high profile issues in the past, and I wonder whether they're right in this case.

Is it possible that they're engaging in a bit of CYA in order to present the worst case scenario just in case something does happen that they did not anticipate - a terror plot that they did not have any clue about?

With that in mind, is this the worst case scenario to be offered in the National Intelligence Estimate, the middle case, or the best case? That's important, since the NIE presents a range of intel opinions. If this is the worst case scenario, what is the best case option? Have we destroyed al Qaeda's capabilities by 75%? 50%? 25%? What's the middle scenario? That's a pretty important question that is unresolved because the NIE is not a public document and we've only been fed one part of the whole.

Accepting this at face value, how is this actually possible? What could possibly have happened that enabled al Qaeda to reconstitute itself? Was it Democrats and anti-war leftists providing talking points to al Qaeda and calling for defeat and retreat from the field of battle - both in Afghanistan and Iraq? That may play a role, but the far more serious problem is what is going on in Pakistan. Musharraf had basically decided to leave the border region with Afghanistan alone, and made deals with the border tribes.
A counterterrorism official familiar with a five-page summary of the document — titled "Al-Qaida better positioned to strike the West" — called it a stark appraisal. The analysis will be part of a broader meeting at the White House on Thursday about an upcoming National Intelligence Estimate.

The official and others spoke to The Associated Press on condition they not be identified because the report remains classified.

The findings suggests that the network that launched the most devastating terror attack on U.S. soil has been able to regroup despite nearly six years of bombings, war and other tactics aimed at dismantling it.

The threat assessment focuses on the terror group's safe haven in Pakistan and makes a range of observations about the threat posed to the United States and its allies, officials said.
Those deals left the region unpoliced and al Qaeda and Taliban and the Islamists in general were able to flourish and reconstitute themselves there. The Lal Masjid siege showed the ultimate folly of appeasement and forced Musharraf to adopt a hard line position against al Qaeda and the Islamists, which in turn forced Zawahiri to release yet another tape in the past week that calls for jihad against Pakistan and Musharraf. That's not a coincidence.

UPDATE:
Musharraf has responded to Zawahiri is very strong terms. He's promised to eradicate the Islamists. Well, I'd start with the region adjacent to Afghanistan, and if the US asks to send its forces into that area to go after al Qaeda, let them and give them all the support they ask for. It's in his best interests as you have to believe that the Islamists are likely to try assassinating Musharraf at the earliest possible opportunity to thwart his efforts:
President Pervez Musharraf says he is determined that extremism and terrorism will be eradicated in Pakistan.
He was speaking in a televised address to the nation after officials said 75 bodies had been found at the radical Red Mosque in Islamabad.

Troops launched a 36 hour attack on the mosque early on Tuesday to flush extremists out of the mosque complex.

For months clerics and students had been defying the authorities in their campaign for Sharia law in the capital.

Students had kidnapped police as well as Islamabad residents they considered to be engaged in un-Islamic activity.
UPDATE:
Congress can't help themselves.
Not quite party line, but almost. Four Republicans voted yes, 10 Dems voted no. It’s the Reed-Levin plan in essence: withdrawal to begin within 120 days of passage and to conclude by April 1, with a small combat force retained in country to target Al Qaeda plus advisors to train the Iraqi army. It’s also a non-starter since Bush has vowed to veto any plan that involves a timetable.
They keep voting for cut and run aka defeat and retreat at every turn, knowing full well that the President will veto any such bill presented to him, and his veto will survive any attempts. Democrats are playing politics with national security. Pure and simple.

They also have paid lip service to the troop surge, which is still coming to bear on al Qaeda and the insurgency, and are more than willing to pull the rug out from under Gen. Petraeus and the US Armed Forces. They are also more than willing to cut and run, leaving millions to a fate that is uncertain at best but all too likely to end in genocidal massacres if history is a guide.

Friday, May 04, 2007

Because They Have Nothing Better To Do

What are Congressional Democrats thinking when they put out ideas like tasking the CIA and other intelligence agencies with trying to track down global warming threats.
Senior House Republicans are complaining about Democrats' plans to divert "scarce" intelligence funds to study global warming.

The House next week will consider the Democrat-crafted Intelligence Authorization bill, which includes a provision directing an assessment of the effects that climate change has on national security.

"Our job is to steal secrets," said Rep. Peter Hoekstra of Michigan, the ranking Republican on the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence.

"There are all kinds of people analyzing global warming," he told The Washington Times. "There's no value added by the intelligence community here; they have no special expertise, and this takes money and resources away from other threats."

Democrats, who outnumber Republicans on the committee, blocked the minority from stripping the warming language from the bill.
That's not their job. And even if it were, would the CIA even get it right? After all, the CIA missed the intel on the fall of the Berlin Wall, the WMD in Iraq, al Qaeda's numerous attacks on the US, etc.

It's not like the CIA doesn't already have a full plate, trying to get a handle on the Islamic terrorist groups and their backers in Iran, Iraq, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Indonesia, and Pakistan. Then, there are the ongoing threats and analysis for places like China and Russia and emerging and continuing threats in places like Venezuela, Cuba, Sudan, and most of Africa, and Southeast Asia.

Where does global warming fit in exactly? It doesn't.

This tells you all you need to know about the priorities of Democrats in Congress. They think global warming is a threat on par with terrorism and that the CIA should task its limited assets to investigating an issue that is already in the purview of agencies like NASA and NOAA along with the Department of the Interior, Department of Commerce, and the EPA.

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Defected

A RETIRED Iranian general who went missing in Turkey last month has defected and sought asylum in the US, according to a well-connected Arabic newspaper published in London.

The newspaper, al-Shark al-Awsat, cited "high-profile" sources saying former Iranian deputy defence minister and Revolutionary Guard commander Ali Reza Asghari had gone over to the West.

Reports from Istanbul that General Asghari's family had also disappeared in Turkey support the likelihood that he defected rather than was kidnapped by either the CIA or by Israel's Mossad, as has been speculated. The general went missing from his Istanbul hotel a month ago.

Iranian authorities, who have been silent on the disappearance until this week, claim he has been abducted. "It is likely Asghari has been abducted by Western intelligence services," said Iran's top police officer, General Esmaeil Ahmadi Moghaddam.

Defection of such a high-ranking figure would leave no external enemy to blame and would be seen as a rejection of the Islamic state by someone who well knows its inner workings.

General Asghari's crossing of the line, whether voluntary or not, is a resounding blow for the Iranian Government since he is privy to its most intimate secrets, particularly those concerning its nuclear capabilities and plans.

He served until two years ago as deputy defence minister, a post he held for eight years and which presumably offered an uninhibited view of virtually every aspect of Iran's security apparatus.
This may leave a serious mark on the Iranian plans for the region. Imagine the information that he is providing on current plans and details on old operations that fill in the blanks.

Another possibility is that he had been providing intel to the West for some time, and now was the time he had to come in from the cold because his situation was going to be uncovered by the Iranian intel agencies. In that case, far from being an intel coup, this is a loss for Western intel assets in the region since they've lost a source on the inside. I doubt we're going to find out which way this news leans for a long time to come.