Showing posts with label Santiago Calatrava. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Santiago Calatrava. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

The Failure of the WTC PATH Hub

Construction of the Port Authority's PATH Transit Hub is still underway and Santiago Calatrava's design shows its final form, even as the cost pushes past a staggering $4 billion. That's nearly $2 billion over the original budget estimate. These inflated costs have sapped the Port Authority's ability to build new infrastructure in the region, which is its core mission. Instead, the agency has poured billions into a project that doesn't add any cross-river capacity.
Set aside the architectural features of the exterior or the fact that the Port Authority is boasting about a transit hall that is larger than that of Grand Central Terminal in Midtown. I think that the design will ultimately be an iconic site in Lower Manhattan and become one of the more photographed sites in Manhattan, which is saying something.

But the visuals can't overcome the serious flaws to the project that will saddle future commuters for generations to come.

The view from Fulton Street.


This is first and foremost a transit hub. So, the first question to be asked is whether it does that job well.

I think I know the answer to this, even though the permanent design is still being unveiled in phases.

The design is a failure.

This week is proof of that.

The new terminal cannot handle counter-commutes. It just can't do it.

The new platforms are all shiny and clad in white marble and the steel ribs that peek out are also white, so you can be forgiven for the impression that you've walked into an Apple store with all the gleaming whiteness and sleek curves.

But getting to the platform itself is a comedy of bad design.

The mezzanine level for the PATH terminal; there is marble as far as the eye can see.

There is currently one platform open, and there are two elevators, which is a significant improvement over the original station or even the temporary station built after the attacks but that's the extent of the positive news. The problem is that the Port Authority decided in its infinite wisdom to build two escalators that funnel into the center of the future transit hall. There are three sets of stairs. During the past two days, it has been next to impossible to get up the stairs or on to the platform level because there simply isn't any room for people to go.

The escalators preclude any counter-commuting. You are forced to go to the stairs at the far ends of the platforms, but considering that we're talking about full trains, there's no extra room for people to squeeze through to get either up or down, so it takes extra time to navigate through the PATH platform level.

That's inexcusable. The Port Authority chose to install costly escalators that they don't even operate full time (they shut down during midday) because of the cost, rather than stairs that would be much more amenable to counter commuting. 

What's sad is that it's actually easier to get from the platform levels to the mezzanine level from the old temporary platforms than it is from the gleaming new platform A. 

It's part of the mindset about the Port Authority thinking only in one direction, and not realizing that there is a significant number of people who commute from Manhattan to New Jersey for their jobs. It's a serious oversight and one that should be corrected with the remaining platforms, but I doubt that they're going to make those changes, even though it would be the prudent thing to do. 

So, who to blame for this? I have to put the blame squarely on the Port Authority, which apparently never bothered to look at how people actually commute, and what can happen when there are service disruptions elsewhere in the system.

The Port Authority loves to claim that there's going to be 250,000 pedestrians using the PATH hub daily, and that there are 35,000 commuters. They can't handle those numbers, and this week shows that the new hub isn't quite up to the task either.


Friday, March 07, 2014

WTC Rebuilding Update - An Expensive Update

The Port Authority continues building the WTC PATH transit hub, and have opened up the first platform of the permanent station. If you were wondering what a $4 billion transit hub can look like, this is what we're getting:





There's wall to wall marble. Everywhere. On the floors of the mezzanine. On the walls. It's omnipresent. The striking Calatrava designed arches and steel components swoop along underground, just as surely as the above ground components are taking shape.

I actually think the below-ground design is likely to age better than the above-ground terminal, which looks like a skeleton or a stegosaurus. The New York Times' David Dunlap panned the efforts thus far.

The Port Authority chose Santiago Calatrava to build the transit hub.

They had $2.2 billion to make this happen. The cost is now $4 billion, and likely to be more than that. We're talking twice as expensive, and that's money that could have gone to extend the 2d Avenue Subway for the Phase 2, extend PATH to Newark Airport, or the LIRR to lower Manhattan. Instead, we've got a glorious transit station that will serve about 50,000 people daily (I'm not counting the connections that have been built to the Fulton Center, which includes the Dey Street Connector).

They blew past the $2.2 billion and never sought to implement the cost controls they claimed they would. That isn’t on Calatrava. That part is on the Port Authority. They chose a design that was far too complex for what is a moderate use station (the original design called for a movable oculus, and that was dropped pretty quickly – about the only good move the Port Authority made here).

But Calatrava isn’t blameless either. His design puts form over function by a wide margin, and his vision constrained the Port Authority once things got underway.

As it is, I think that the actual access to the platforms is inadequate considering the size of the platforms. There is a constant bottleneck at the stairs/escalators. The stairs feel narrower than those at the temporary platforms, and that means people trying to get down to the platform choke the flow even further.

You would have thought passenger flow would have been a paramount concern, but it appears to have been an afterthought. But at least the escalators talk incessantly about not letting children ride alone, not walking or running up the escalators, and holding the handrails.

The materials chosen are just the outward symbol of excess spending, but it’s the execution of the station that is the most troubling aspect. Calatrava thinks that if only more money were spent, he’d get what he envisioned.

What riders and the PANY should be asking is how did we spend this much to get a station that falls short in so many ways. There are so many missed opportunities here, and we're stuck with a design that is too costly and doesn't live up to the expectations.

Still, I imagine that once the main hall is built, I might warm up to the design, but for now, it looks like the Port Authority and Calatrava did a poor job of keeping costs down – and that controlling costs was never part of the bargain.

Tuesday, June 07, 2011

The Port Authority Plans 25% Hikes In Tolls Citing Shortfalls and WTC Construction

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey is expected to raise tolls on the bistate agency's bridges and tunnels by the end of the year. The tolls would likely rise to $10 from $8 and off-peak discounts are likely to be cut. PATH fares are also likely to increase.
The agency runs the George Washington Bridge and Lincoln and Holland tunnels as well as the Goethals and Bayonne bridges and the Outerbridge Crossing.

The same tolls apply on all six crossings.

Peak hours are defined as 6 to 9 a.m. and 4 to 7 p.m. on weekdays, and noon to 8 p.m. on weekends.

A toll hike would likely come with a proposal to raise fares on the PATH train.

It would not, however, include an increase in surcharges at the agency's airports or seaports.

Once flush with cash, the agency's coffers have taken huge hits in recent years and it badly needs the $300 million the $2 increase would bring in.

The biggest financial drains have been the growing expense of rebuilding the World Trade Center, which came as the recession caused a massive decline in tolls and other fees from commuting, air travel and maritime cargo.
The Port Authority cites construction at Ground Zero as part of the reason it needs the higher fares and both Gov. Chris Christie and Gov. Andrew Cuomo are expected to sign off on the hikes.

What doesn't get mentioned is the fact that the serious cost overruns at the PATH hub at Ground Zero are a major reason that the Port Authority is in dire need of the toll hike. Originally expected to cost $2.2 billion, the project is now running upwards of $3.4 billion, and is likely to be much closer to $3.8 billion.

Considering that the PANY is over its original budget estimate by more than $1.2 billion (or $400 million if you're working from their more recent figures), that $400 million would have more than mitigated the need for fare hikes.

This shows that the Port Authority was not serious about containing costs on the PATH hub, and that inability is leading to commuters having to incur additional costs to cover the agency's operating and capital budget programs. The Port Authority has repeatedly claimed that it was taking steps to contain costs, but that doesn't appear to have occurred, particularly with the Transit Hub.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 134

Santiago Calatrava's PATH Transit Hub
Just about six weeks ago, the cost of the WTC transit hub was expected to run about $3.4 billion. Now, there are reports it's going to cost $3.8 billion, and that would make it the most expensive component of the rebuilding efforts at Ground Zero, exceeding those of even the Freedom Tower (1WTC) or the WTC memorial and museum. Just a few years ago, the cost was not expected to be more than $2.2 billion and efforts were undertaken to reduce the costs.
The final price is expected to climb to $3.8 billion — $400 million over its current budget and 70 percent more than initial estimates, according to documents obtained by The Record.

The latest projected increase is laid out in a report written by a federal monitor shortly after Port Authority officials increased the project's budget from $3.2 billion to $3.4 billion in late February.

The report warns that — even after the controversial February increase — the "budget still does not appear adequate for the ultimate completion of the project." It adds: "Recent discussions with the Port Authority" indicate a $3.8 billion final price tag. The 2005 budget for the project was $2.2 billion.

The hub, which will serve as a gateway to Manhattan for tens of thousands of New Jersey commuters each day, is also facing a three-month delay, with completion now expected in March 2015, the report states.

Officials at the Port Authority, the bi-state agency in charge of the federally funded project, brushed aside the estimate.

"We remain confident in our budget" of $3.4 billion, spokesman John Kelly said.

And an official at the Federal Transit Administration, which is paying a majority of the hub expenses, stressed that the authority could still hit its current spending target if it manages the project properly.

Designed by Spanish architect Santiago Calatrava, the hub will house a new PATH station and connect to 13 subway lines.
The Port Authority is under tremendous financial strain, and the new projected price tag means that the Port Authority will have to come up with hundreds of millions of dollars in increased funds - which means that fares and tolls may have to increase to cover the costs of rebuilding at Ground Zero.

Once built, the PATH hub will connect with the oft-delayed Fulton Street Transit Hub and connect 13 subway lines using an underground passage underneath Dey Street. The Fulton Street hub project is finally proceeding with steel installation of its signature element - an above-ground oculus that allows light to enter into the deeper recesses of the massive tangle of station platforms and connecting pathways.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 128

Is it surprising to anyone that the costs for various parts of the Ground Zero rebuilding continue to exceed estimates? The latest part to see cost overruns is the Santiago Calatrava's PATH transit hub. The price tag has gone up another $220 million, to $3.4 billion.

As it was originally proposed, the project would be $2.2 billion. The price tag was estimated at $3.2 billion in 2008, and an effort to control costs included reworking certain parts of the design, including the use of Vierendeel trusses to maintain an open feel to certain parts of the hub.

The cost increases were attributed to higher costs for steel installation and contracts to do that work.

Meanwhile, the National 9/11 Memorial Museum has launched an online timeline showing events from 9/11 in real time, from the moment that the 19 terrorists went through screening at the airports until President Bush's speech to the nation that evening.
The National September 11th Memorial Museum has launched an online timeline, using graphic video from the attacks on the World Trade Center.

The site features video of the towers collapsing, as well as recordings of victims' final phone calls and oral histories of survivors.

Museum curators hope the site helps people understand how the events of 9/11 unfolded, through the eyes of those who were involved.

"The main purpose of doing this is for people who want to learn about 9/11. To take a very chaotic day, make some sense of it, understand the key points in time and some of the stories behind it," said National 9/11 Memorial & Museum President Joe Daniels.

"It gives you a real deeply textured sense of what that person saw, thought, heard or felt, whether it's a first responder or a survivor," said National 9/11 Memorial & Museum Curator Amy Weinstein.

Wednesday, October 06, 2010

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 116

Construction is proceeding all around Ground Zero as the Freedom Tower (1WTC) and 4WTC both rise gradually above the site. The museum and memorial spaces continue to be built out.

At the same time, the Winter Garden, which is located in the World Financial Center across West Street and was wrecked by falling debris on 9/11 is in for a makeover. The Winter Garden had connected to the World Trade Center with a pedestrian bridge before the 9/11 attacks, but the new WTC complex will connect with the World Financial Center via an underground passage that will link up with the Santiago Calatrava-designed transit hub and the upgraded Fulton Street station.

The Winter Garden is one of the grand public spaces in the City and the staircase is one of the reasons.

However, the underground connector means that the current grand staircase may disappear so that the frontage with West Street can be opened up. Brookfield Properties, which operates the Winter Garden, has proposed a new design for the building.
Brookfield also plans to create a two-level market and 714-seat food court in the retail space just south of the Winter Garden, with cafes and test kitchens by the city’s top restaurateurs.

David Cheikin, vice president of leasing for Brookfield, said he hopes to revive the Financial Center’s sleepy, underutilized retail by serving local residents in addition to office workers.

"We believe we can take [the WFC] from a five-day-a-week retail corridor to a seven-day [corridor]," Cheikin said Monday night.

Many Battery Park City residents strongly object to demolishing the Grand Staircase, which was rebuilt after 9/11 and has since become a place of community gathering. City Planning Commissioner Amanda Burden also wants to preserve the stairs.

However, Brookfield executives said that if the stairs stay in place, they would create a choke point by blocking the exit of the new pedestrian tunnel beneath West Street, scheduled to open by the end of 2012.

"We like those stairs, too," Lawrence Graham, a Brookfield vice president, told CB1 Monday. "We wish we could have found something different. Obviously, it would have been cheaper for us [to keep the stairs in place]."
Meanwhile, Fiterman Hall is rising adjacent to 7WTC between West Broadway and Greenwich Streets. Steel has reached 6 stories above street level.

It will start receiving the brick cladding on its exterior in coming weeks and the exterior work should be complete within a year.

At the same time, the Port Authority is looking to restart talks over the fate of the St. Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church, which was destroyed by the collapsing towers. The site is adjacent to the former Deutsche Bank building, which is thankfully in the final stages of demolition more than nine years after the attacks.

UPDATE:
A LMDC Committee is proposing a reallocation of funds to cover construction of a performing arts center, which may end up being built on the site of the former Deutsche Bank building. The Joyce Theater is the primary tenant for the performing arts center, but it is quite likely to be joined by at least one other group so as to make the most of the space.
A committee of the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation on Wednesday recommended that the corporation allocate up to $100 million for the performing arts center planned for ground zero. The money would come from a pool of some $200 million formerly designated for utility companies. At the corporation’s Wednesday board meeting, Kate D. Levin, the New York City cultural affairs commissioner, said the money was important “to fulfill this critical part of the master plan.”

The financing, which requires approval by the full board, would add to $50 million in federal money set aside for the project, which is controlled by the development corporation. Still unresolved is whether to build the performing arts center on the World Trade Center site, as called for in the master plan, or at 130 Liberty Street, site of the former Deutsche Bank building. The center’s primary tenant is to be the Joyce Theater, which presents dance.

Friday, August 20, 2010

Cordoba House Controversy Update

The New York Daily News is running with a story about how construction workers in the City wont work on the project.
A growing number of New York construction workers are vowing not to work on the mosque planned near Ground Zero.

"It's a very touchy thing because they want to do this on sacred ground," said Dave Kaiser, 38, a blaster who is working to rebuild the World Trade Center site.

"I wouldn't work there, especially after I found out about what the imam said about U.S. policy being responsible for 9/11," Kaiser said.

The grass-roots movement is gaining momentum on the Internet. One construction worker created the "Hard Hat Pledge" on his blog and asked others to vow not to work on the project if it stays on Park Place.

"Thousands of people are signing up from all over the country," said creator Andy Sullivan, a construction worker from Brooklyn. "People who sell glass, steel, lumber, insurance. They are all refusing to do work if they build there."
Don't expect that to stop construction, if this project secures its financing though.

Just expect to see the big rat for nonunion work, as seen at other nonunion jobs elsewhere in the City. It would just add to the opposition to the construction near Ground Zero.

If anyone thought that the proposed community center was uniformly backed by the Muslim community, you'd be wrong. Similarly, if you thought that 9/11 victims families were of one mind on the project, you too would be wrong.



Former Mayor Rudy Giuliani has come out in support of Gov. Paterson's proposal to relocate the site, all while asking tough questions of the proposal's backers. He's got a point about the sensitivity issue - if Imam Rauf and the Cordoba Initiative were truly interested in building bridges between the Muslim community and those who lost loved ones in 9/11, they'd be much more open about their plans and avoid saying insensitive statements, or potentially inflammatory ones (like claiming that they would obtain financing from Saudi Arabia and Iran) or that the community center is nowhere near Ground Zero (which strains credulity) or that some buildings in the City have their own ZIP codes (the former WTC did - 10048).

That's even as the US State Department going back to the Bush Administration used Rauf as a pointman on building ties between the Muslim community and Americans. Indeed, Rauf was in Bahrain where he said that he wanted to Americanize Islam.
“This issue of extremism is something that has been a national security issue — not only for the United States but also for many countries and nations in the Muslim world,” Rauf told Associated Press Television News.

“This is why this particular trip has a great importance because all countries in the Muslim world — as well as the Western world — are facing this ... major security challenge.”

Rauf also said he has been working on a way to “Americanize Islam,” although he did not elaborate on what an American version of Islam might look like.

“The same principles and rituals were everywhere, but what happened in different regions was there were different interpretations,” he said. “So we recognize that our heritage allows for re-expressing the internal principles of our religion in different cultural times and places.”

The comments differ greatly from what Rauf said in December 2001. Just two months after the 9/11 attacks, the imam wasn't so quick to condemn radical religious beliefs in his own faith.

"The United States' policies were an accessory to the crime that happened, because we have been an accessory to a lot of innocent lives dying in the world," he said during an interview on CBS's "60 Minutes. "In fact, in the most direct sense, Osama bin Laden is made in the USA."
That's the kind of statement that would get him in trouble with the fundamentalists like al Qaeda (Salafists, Wahabis, and even among the mad mullahs of Iran).

UPDATE:
Does John Podhoretz live in New York City? Has he even visited Lower Manhattan in the last few months? Because his latest op-ed is riddled with bogus information. While it is true that the Ground Zero master plan was botched by then Gov. George Pataki and his chosen designer Daniel Libeskind, the Port Authority has moved on with the assistance of SOM, Foster and Partners, Santiago Calatrava, and several other major firms to design skyscrapers and integral features for Ground Zero including the museum/memorial (memorial designed by Michael Arad).

The actual memorials are well underway and will be completed by next year. The fact is that you can't view them from street level because the structure of those memorials are at bedrock - 70 feet below street level. It looks like there's no work done on them because the work is obscured by the security cordons around the site, and the rising Freedom Tower (now at more than 34 stories).

You can see the progress from the World Financial Center and any of the towers surrounding the site. Heck, if John simply read this site on a regular basis (or even the NY Post columns by Steve Cuozzo or Tom Toupousis) he'd know that work is progressing all over the site - with much of it still obscured because it is at or below street level.

The work (or lack thereof) at Ground Zero from late 2001 through the present did not create the conditions in which SoHo Properties could purchase and develop the property. The owners of that building wanted to sell, and found themselves a willing buyer in the SoHo Properties.

The Port Authority didn't control that site. Neither did the City. The LMDC didn't purchase the building and didn't consider it worthy of being purchased. That latter point may well have been an oversight - but given that the LMDC couldn't demolish the former Deutsche Bank building without major catastrophes - fires, deaths, negligence and rampant safety problems - there's no way to say that the building would have been in any better hands.

Saturday, August 14, 2010

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 110

While much of the focus is on the Cordoba House project two blocks north (despite the fact that two other mosques are within walking distance of Ground Zero), progress continues on the Freedom Tower. And yes, the whole mess with the Cordoba House has gotten to the point where President Obama not only had to chime in, but then had to play it both ways. What a way to take a principled stand, where the US Constitution protects the proponent's right to build, just as surely as it protects the rights of everyone else to complain about it being built. That's one of the foundations of this great nation.



But as to why so many people are opposed to the project, maybe it has to do with the fact that so many people have gotten their information from a media that continues to botch the facts. That goes for Charles Krauthammer too, who ought to know better.

Moreover, the same people who claim that the mosque doesn't belong near Ground Zero (that is when they aren't conflating matters by claiming the mosque will be in Ground Zero) don't care that there's a strip club about the same distance from Ground Zero or that millions of square feet of office space are set to rise from Ground Zero - the space where nearly 3,000 people were murdered.

Despite all the focus elsewhere, the Freedom Tower is growing about three stories every week.

Right now, it's 34 stories tall, and the tower cranes are starting to peek over the Battery Park City buildings, which means that it wont be long before the tower itself is visible from across the Hudson River.

The Port Authority's photo stream is here. This photo shows the WTC Memorials and the footprints coming to fruition. If you're at street level, you can't see what's going on around the site because of the updated blue wraps that deter people from looking into the site. That includes the Santiago Calatrava designed transit hub for PATH.

Most of the work around Ground Zero is still below ground level, but 1WTC (Freedom Tower) and 4WTC (diagonally across the site) are rising with new steel added daily.

Wednesday, December 02, 2009

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 88

Groundbreaking on the new Fiterman Hall took place yesterday, but it was not without a bit of controversy sparked by none other than the irritable and despicable New York City Councilman Charles Barron, who took offense with not being on the dais for the ceremony and got into a shouting match with a CUNY Trustee.
Barron accused Mayor Bloomberg and others of "disrespecting" him and the students who had fought for a new building.

"The mayor gets up here and doesn't even respect us enough to even mention that students were even involved in it at all," Barron said during the groundbreaking for Fiterman Hall at Borough of Manhattan Community College.

At that point, CUNY trustee Jeffrey Wiesenfeld rose from his front-row seat and said, "When was the last time you respected somebody? You're a disgrace!"

"You be quiet. No one's talking to you," shot back Barron, chairman of the council's Higher Education Committee, as a couple of hundred invited guests looked on in wonderment. "You're a sickening racist, so you can go to hell!"

When Wiesenfeld told Barron to await his turn to speak, the councilman retorted: "Whether you like it or not, I'm here and I'm not going nowhere."
The exchange is here:



Even as the groundbreaking was underway, Steve Cuozzo reminds everyone that Fiterman Hall could have been refurbished and rebuilt following the damage sustained in the 9/11 attacks. The years of delays in securing financing led to the very problems alleged - mold infestations that proved too much to clean:
So after it was damaged on 9/11, CUNY held out for a whole new building. The original very likely could have been fixed -- but, as then-Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff told us in 2004, "They don't think it's the ideal building for their purposes."

If it was truly beyond repair, CUNY never proved it. Although it had $120 million in insurance funds for repairs, it wanted $56 million more from the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation to knock it down and start over -- holding the eyesore hostage for years as it cast a pall on the doorstep of the new 7 World Trade Center.

The Fiterman fiasco bounced back and forth among CUNY, three governors and City Hall. When the LMDC finally agreed to put in more dough, CUNY designed a fancier building and demanded even more money. Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver squeezed a reluctant Mayor Bloomberg to pump $70 million into a bloated $259 million tab.

By the time CUNY got everything it wanted, Fiterman Hall had finally turned as toxic as the school first claimed -- further delaying demolition.
Meanwhile, a look around Ground Zero would reveal a hive of construction on multiple projects. There are at least nine heavy lift cranes operating around the site - four alone at the Freedom Tower, including two tower cranes. Two other tower cranes are operating at Ground Zero, not counting the tower crane for the ongoing demolition of the former Deutsche Bank building, which appears to have had it's current top floor demolished by the look of the scaffolding slowly coming down.

Steel continues rising on the Freedom Tower (1WTC), and the steel crosswork and angular form of the lower floors of the tower are starting to come into focus.

At the same time, construction is underway throughout the temporary PATH station, including new stair access to the subway platforms and overlaying and interlacing the Calatrava design on top of the existing structures. It strikes me as a tremendous waste of money to see so much of the temporary station demolished; it was built with five tracks and three platforms, but two of the tracks are now fully out of commission and one platform is out of service. Was it necessary to build that additional capacity in the temporary station when the final design would require their demolition? It would have made more sense to pare down the temporary station so that construction could proceed, saving everyone money in the process.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 84

The Port Authority has scored itself on whether it met 24 goals for the third quarter of 2009 in its rebuilding efforts at Ground Zero. It said that the Port Authority met or exceeded 21 of 24 goals. It notes that the demolition of the former Deutsche Bank building was behind schedule, but it wasn't the Port Authority's fault since the building demolition was the responsibility of the LMDC and LMCCC.

The Port Authority indicates that one of the goals for the Freedom Tower (1WTC) is that it will reach 20 stories during the 1st quarter of 2010. Right now, we're about three stories.

Here are the goals accomplished to date:
* Installed 10,000 tons of steel and 80,000 cubic yards of concrete for Port Authority projects on the WTC site.
* Installed more than 7,500 tons of steel for the National September 11 Memorial & Museum.
* Over 51,000 cubic yards of concrete has been placed for One World Trade Center, which now rises 105 feet above street level.
* Over 2,300 cubic yards of concrete has been placed and 15 slurry panels have been completed to date for the new Vehicle Security Center.
* More than 1000 construction workers on site.
* 51 Calatrava arches have been installed for the East-West Connector of the World Trade Center Transportation Hub.
In the first quarter of 2010, the following work is expected to be undertaken, including the first shipment of roof steel for the transportation hub.

The Freedom Tower is expected to be built out by 2013 as is the full 9/11 memorial and museum. A portion of the 9/11 memorial is expected to be open by the 10th anniversary.

Thursday, May 21, 2009

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 67

Costs continue spiraling out of control, and years of delays have brought us to this current mess. It's now expected to cost $1.1 billion more to build the transit hub at the World Trade Center, and that's not even taking into account the mess surrounding the office tower construction, which assumes that Larry Silverstein and the Port Authority can agree on extending Silverstein's credit line.
The World Trade Center Transportation Hub is near-certain to bust its $3.2 billion budget - and there's a chance it will cost more than $4.3 billion to build, the Daily News has learned.

That's a spike of as much as $1.1 billion from the Port Authority's "clear-eyed" estimate of only eight months ago, a review of Hub costs obtained by The News under the Freedom of Information Act reveals.

The December report by the Federal Transit Administration says it's 90% certain the Port Authority will blow a June 2014 deadline for opening the Santiago Calatrava-designed megaterminal.

The FTA study also estimated there's a 50-50 chance the Hub could cost $3.8 billion, shattering its budget by $600 million - with no funding for the extra costs.

"Project costs significantly exceed available FTA and local funding," the 61-page consultant's study said.
There's a 90% chance that the transit hub will run $4.4 billion, and a 10% chance that it will go over $5 billion.

The original WTC, including the PATH station, was built for $1.5 billion. The PATH transit hub allows New Jersey residents to access Lower Manhattan where they work. It will be connected to the similarly overbudget and overdue Fulton Street Transit Hub, which isn't expected to be completed until 2014 at the earliest. That project was originally expected to be completed this year, but anyone looking out at the work site can see only a hole in the ground, and no sign that it will be completed anytime soon.

At the same time, a revised WTC now includes stumps where towers were to be built, and this is a travesty and sign that the Port Authority has no interest in building for the future.
Renderings of the proposal have been quietly circulating among some downtown officials and were obtained by The Post yesterday.

The retail podiums would anchor as much as 600,000 square feet of shopping space that would extend below street level into every WTC building and through the massive Calatrava transit hub.

By building podiums in place of towers, PA officials expect to increase the amount of retail space from the currently planned 500,000 square feet -- roughly what existed in the World Trade Center before 9/11.

Silverstein has opposed building two podiums, and has asked the PA to act as a backstop in his bid to finance two of his three WTC towers. He recently offered to delay construction of his third tower.

PA officials have not budged, and have agreed to back him on only one tower, WTC 4, at the corner of Liberty and Greenwich streets.

The Ground Zero developer has insisted that by the time he completes two towers between 2013 and 2015, the economy will have turned around and the demand for high-end office space will have returned.
Silverstein is the only optimist among the bunch, and he wants to rebuild office space that he knows will fill up as the economy recovers, and will encourage business to flock to Lower Manhattan. The fact is that if the stumps are built, it will mean that Ground Zero will remain a work site indefinitely as construction looms over the site for decades- rather than the much shorter timeframe if the work is started and completed in one shot.

Silverstein is pushing to get office towers built, and needs a credit line extended because the credit markets are still woozy. This would be a prime opportunity for the Obama Administration to step in and provide that credit since it would provide the shovel ready project that Obama so desperately craves, and which would bolster local Democrats who support construction and rebuilding at Ground Zero.

It's time for the President to step up to the plate and make this happen. The memories of the fallen, and the City, State, and the nation deserve as much.

Friday, September 26, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 50

It appears that the Port Authority has come to its senses and has figured out a way to not only build the 9/11 memorial and have it open in time for the 10th anniversary, but to "save costs" on the PATH terminal that runs through the site.
The proposal to meet the 2011 deadline was made possible in part by a modification of the design for the transit hub mezzanine, a column-free space that will lie directly under part of the memorial plaza. With the help of the architect Santiago Calatrava, the authority would insert four to six columns to hold up a platform on which the memorial plaza would be built, while the mezzanine was constructed below. The plan would retain Mr. Calatrava’s grand vision for the undulating ceiling and clean expanse of the mezzanine and the dramatic birdlike design of the main building, or oculus, at street level.
The cost to build the PATH terminal is still expected to run to nearly $3 billion from current estimates of $2.5 billion and the terminal isn't expected to be open until 2014. That's unacceptable, and should be completed far sooner and at lower cost than they're claiming. Part of the problem is that the pace (a lack of urgency I've commented on before) is causing serious costs to be incurred because materials are increasing costs even if the design doesn't change. The faster the construction is built, the less it would actually cost. By dragging this out, we're incurring charges that could be avoided.

The NY Observer notes that some are calling for benchmarks to be established to make sure the Port Authority makes its deadlines.

I'm sure that the news about the memorial will help improve Steve Cuozzo's outlook on Ground Zero rebuilding, but he's been downright cranky over the PATH terminal and the building of transit infrastructure that he believes puts the cart before the horse - instead of focusing on the memorial, museum, and then office space, significant costs are going to the transit hub that would be better spent elsewhere. The problem is that once the towers start going up, there's no real estate to build the transit hub, and that's why every inch on the site is literally fought over time and time again.

It's also why Calatrava had to give in on the columns - it made the rest of the project actually work. I don't quite get why it would take until 2014 until the terminal is completed. There's no reason that the terminal should take that long to finish, and are they actually saying that the temporary entrance on Vesey at Greenwich will remain as a permanent edifice until 2014?

So, why did the Port Authority proffer this information and make it known that they can make the 10th anniversary deadline for the memorial? Well, a report comes out next week authored by Chris Ward, who was told by Gov. Paterson to get to the bottom of this and figure out what's going on. They want to get ahead of the curve and try to show that the Port Authority can make good on its word.

I'm not totally buying it, especially since the Port Authority has been dragging its feet throughout the entire process from the moment that the PATH service was restored in record time and a temporary platform built. Since then, the agency hasn't exactly conducted itself as though there's any urgency to rebuilding, and that mindset starts at the top - the governors of NY (Pataki, Spitzer, and now Paterson). They would talk a good game, but when everything was on the line, little was accomplished.

UPDATE:
The Port Authority is going to miss yet another deadline to turn over sections of Ground Zero to Larry Silverstein so that he can build the towers. The Port Authority has lagged at every step of the way, costing tens of millions of dollars in penalties in the process.
The Port Authority was supposed to turn over the site to Silverstein Properties on June 30 and since then has incurred a $300,000-a-day penalty, which it must pay the developer. Earlier this month, the Port Authority said it would turn the site over by the end of September, but according to a number of sources, that deadline will not be met.

As of the end of September, the Port Authority will have incurred $18 million in penalties for the Tower 2 site. That figure, coupled with the $14.4 million the Port Authority paid as a result of a previous missed deadline, pushes the authority's total penalties over the $30 million threshold. If the Port Authority fails to hand over the site by the end of October, the penalties will be more than $40 million.

A spokesman for the Port Authority, Steve Coleman, said the agency still plans to turn the site for Tower 2 over by the end of the month.
And you wonder why I wonder about the urgency to rebuild and get the towers built? That's it in a nutshell.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

9/11: Seven Years Later

*** This post will remain on the top of the page. Scroll down for other coverage. ***

It's hard to believe that seven years have passed since that incredibly awful day. I can still remember it as vividly now as I could on that morning. Here's what I wrote for the six year anniversary, and much of what was written then is just as valid today. Many still are tormented and challenged by the emotional demons and physical scars of that day, wondering how they were able to survive when so many of their friends, colleagues, and others didn't.

Even though the horrors of that day have receded into memory, the scars of that day are present, even if they are just below the surface. Health concerns remain an issue and this past week, the cause of death for NYPD officer James Zadroga was reargued as a New Yorker article presented still more evidence that he died not of 9/11 related inhalation of Ground Zero dust, but of pain killers. That has serious repercussions for the thousands of others seeking additional benefits from the city, state, and federal government claiming that they too were harmed by inhaling Ground Zero air.
In June, the city released a detailed analysis of medical records of 10,000 people suing for Ground Zero-related benefits: It showed that 30 percent had only nominal health issues, that many had no current health problems and that others were claiming illnesses that couldn't possibly be linked to 9/11.

Indeed, the survey more than justified City Hall's refusal simply to pay out billions to anyone simply claiming a 9/11-related illness.

Which is why we fail to understand why Mayor Bloomberg and Health Commissioner Thomas Frieden are now taking the opposite approach - by inviting New Yorkers to claim victimhood.

The city recently launched a $5 million ad campaign urging anyone who lived or worked in Lower Manhattan in the aftermath of 9/11 to come forward.
While we must do all we can to treat those workers who are affected with lasting respiratory effects, ensuring that others do not take advantage of the large sums of money being spent on 9/11 health issues is important as well.

As for the actual construction at Ground Zero, there has been some serious progress, but there remain serious setbacks and delays.

The first steel beams for the 9/11 Memorial are finally being erected, and there are questions over whether this was just symbolic or a real tangible step forward. Given how there was tremendous fanfare when Gov. Pataki laid the cornerstone of the Freedom Tower several years ago, it's a valid question. After that cornerstone was laid, no work was actually done on the Tower and the Port Authority had to move the cornerstone to a different location altogether because of security concerns over the Tower's initial siting. Still, a look around the Ground Zero work site and you can see construction progressing. A new rendition of the 9/11 Memorial and Museum has been released (more here), and two of the easily recognizable tridents from the original Twin Towers will be incorporated as central features of the museum.
Though the broad outlines of the design have been known for some time, the unveiling on Tuesday provided and confirmed some key details about the $80 million pavilion, which is being financed by New York State. The polygonal pavilion will range in height from 57 to 72 feet (roughly equal to a six-story office building). It will contain 47,499 square feet of floor area; 34,834 square feet devoted to public programs and museum functions, the rest to ventilating ductwork and mechanical equipment serving the underground museum, the nearby World Trade Center Transportation Hub and the No. 1 subway line.

The ground floor will have ticket windows, a large security area in which visitors will undergo airport-style screening, and a staircase, escalators and elevators down which they will begin a trip that will lead them nearly 70 feet below street level, ending near an exposed part of the slurry wall. There will also be exit doors ushering them into the heart of the memorial plaza.

On the second floor will be a 180-seat auditorium, a private room in which relatives of 9/11 victims may gather, an overlook from which visitors can take in a sweeping view of the memorial, and a small cafe. (”For sustenance,” Mr. Dykers said, “not a restaurant per se.”)

The third floor will be given over entirely to equipment and ventilation.
The museum is set to open in 2012 (the 11th anniversary), a year after the memorial, which is scheduled to open by 9/11/2011. [note: fixed the preceding paragraph to clarify when the museum and memorial are to be open to the public.]

Steel is rising at the Freedom Tower, though it is barely poking above street level. Concrete bathtubs have been poured along the Church Street and Greenwich Street corridor, enabling the construction of 2, 3, and 4 WTC.

The former Deutsche Bank building is still a hulking ruin continues to loom large over the rest of the site. Fiterman Hall isn't much better. PATH has a temporary station for its temporary station, as construction on the Santiago Calatrava transit center is underway. The PATH service has been uninterrupted, but there are concerns about serious cost overruns that might result in changes to the Calatrava plan. Many aspects of his plan have been scaled back, but construction is well underway for the East/West connector that would guide customers to the PATH terminal from the World Financial Center and the general plan is moving foward.

7WTC looks like it is going to be a huge success for Larry Silverstein, as it continues to garner new tenants to fill out its space.

Businesses around Lower Manhattan continue to struggle not only because of current economic conditions, but because of construction blocking pedestrian traffic including the Fulton Street Transit Hub, and this article takes a closer look at three which relocated after their locations were destroyed by the collapsing Twin Towers.

A new 9/11 related curriculum is being launched for high schools across the country. 9/11 related charities are evolving and expanding from their core mission as their original mission goals were satisfied or funding has dried up or the charities have ceased to exist.
"We've been able to evolve, to reflect the ongoing and changing needs of 9/11," said Gardner, executive director of the nonprofit, now based in Brick Township.

Gardner's experience is typical of 9/11 charities. Many of the hundreds of organizations and funds that sprang up after the attacks have closed down, disappeared or changed direction as funding streams for 9/11 programs have dried up and donors have turned to other causes.

In New Jersey alone, a majority of the 30 organizations launched that year have ceased operating or disappeared. In some cases, the work stopped when money was gone. While the major disaster funds ran out of cash, other sources simply turned their attention to other problems and programs, 9/11 charity officials say.

"It's made fundraising difficult," said Gardner, whose brother, Harvey, died in the attack on the North Tower. "The (early) focus was on spending the relief funds down. But that is to the detriment of 9/11 groups struggling to continue to provide services."
This year will also mark the opening of the 9/11 memorial at the Pentagon. A North Jersey lighting company was involved in the construction of the memorial, which includes 186 benches cantilevered over small pools which are lit from the underside. A photo of the memorial can be seen here. There remain security concerns about having a public memorial so close to the nerve center for the US military, but it is the right thing to do. That memorial cost $22 million and will be open 24/7 beginning September 11 of this year.

Compare that with the $1 billion and counting that will go to the 9/11 memorial at Ground Zero. It's not easy to compare the sites, given what is involved and the sheer size of the projects and what is envisioned for the site.

Construction is also moving along on the Shanksville memorial to Flight 93, even as some families wonder how the design was approved with clear Islamic influence - the shape of the memorial is that of an Islamic crescent, and which is oriented towards Mecca. Local businesses and politicians are trying to figure out how to handle the influx of people that would come to the memorial site, including other business opportunities for tourism.

Flopping Aces has much more on the Shanksville Memorial.

Anyone who walks around Ground Zero in Manhattan would find people selling photos or books of the 9/11 attacks, along with photos of the day. I find that somewhat crass, but at the same time, it's important that people see what happened that day and not forget what happened. The further away from 9/11 we get, the more the details fade away. It is just too important to let that happen.

Then again, there are plenty of people who don't quite get what happened on 9/11 is a reflection of an ongoing war by Islamists against the US. They don't (as seen by comments here). It can be traced back to the the PLO hijackings of the 1970s, Iranian attack on the US Embassy in Tehran in 1979, and through to the Hizbullah bombing of the US Marine Barracks in 1983, the 1993 WTC bombing (which happened 15 years ago), and then the attacks on the US Embassies in Africa, the USS Cole, to say nothing of the dozens of terror attacks in between.

The failure treat the Islamist threat seriously convinced Islamic terrorist group leaders, including Osama bin Laden, that they could launch ever more audacious attacks to impose their view on the world - to force the US to leave its allies hanging and to enable the Islamists to establish dominion. It was only after 9/11 that the US responded to the Islamists' war on the US with the kind of vigor necessary to defeat the Islamists.

Al Qaeda and the Islamists disdain for non believers grew increasingly violent as they saw that they could attack and attack without repercussions. They saw that there were tremendous weaknesses in US will and security, and they took advantage of it, to deadly effect. Now, they have to spend more time watching their backs than plotting future attacks.

Meanwhile, the Port Authority is in the process of reducing its police presence around the Port Authority Bus Terminal as a cost-cutting measure. I think that's a short sighted idea given that the Islamic terrorists who hit on 9/11 have had compatriots who have repeatedly sought to attack Port Authority operations - including the Holland and Lincoln Tunnels and the PATH system. Such is the state of affairs at Ground Zero and related operations in 2008.

And after spending years on the sidelines barely paying attention to Ground Zero redevelopment, and offering up platitudes and complaints about the need to rebuild office space (instead pushing residential use over commercial space), Mayor Bloomberg is now pushing to have a greater say in Ground Zero redevelopment. That's not going to help redevelopment and may actually slow it down further as Bloomberg pushes his own ideas. Still, Bloomberg is right on the money by calling on the Port Authority to complete the 9/11 memorial by the 10th anniversary and to scale back the PATH transit hub. Of course, the Port Authority is already moving in that direction on both counts, so it's a bit like preaching to the converted. The Mayor would also like to dismantle the LMDC, which has overseen rebuilding throughout the site, and has had ownership of the former Deutsche Bank building. Instead, the LMDC oversight would be put in the hands of the Lower Manhattan Construction Command Center (LMCCC), which is a city-state agency that is managing the development of the site and coordinating construction projects in Lower Manhattan.

As for the actual commemoration taking place on the 11th, here's a list of street closures in Lower Manhattan, a list of events around the region, and other local observances around the country.

Also, the public is invited to come down to Battery Park and sign steel beams that will be incorporated into the 9/11 Memorial at Ground Zero today (the 10th, and 11th) (via Mrs. Lawhawk).

A new 9/11 memorial was dedicated on Tuesday in Boston, which is where American Airlines Flight 11 and United Airlines Flight 175 departed from Logan on Sept. 11, 2001.

Freedom Tower rising 7/08 by lawhawk (c) 2008

UPDATE:
Curbed has many more WTC construction photos.

ADDENDUM:
As I now work in Lower Manhattan within view of Ground Zero, I rode to work this morning (as I normally do) on PATH, which runs through Ground Zero. I had the opportunity and privilege of being inside Ground Zero this morning within the time frame of the first plane hitting while sitting on the PATH train. We stopped before entering Ground Zero at the moment the first plane hit. It was an eerie feeling and one of tremendous sadness. The crowd of people that surges through the PATH station was quieter than normal, which I attribute to the solemnity of the day. I had thought I would take photos of the site and the commemorations in and around Ground Zero, but I realized that I simply could not. The emotions are far too raw, and the protesters - and they will get their undue coverage - made my blood boil.

You had your Troofers - those who engage in conspiracy mongering about who was behind the 9/11 attacks. You have the blame Bush crowd - complete with banners claiming that Bush was behind the terrorist attacks. And then you had several people claiming to be soldiers against the war in Iraq. They too had swarms of photographers and journalists photographing and taking video.

To me, the more poignant views were those of the family members clutching photos of their loved ones, many of whose remains were never recovered. They buried empty caskets. There were the firefighters and police officers from around the region and the country who are coming to pay respects to their brothers who made the supreme sacrifices by running into the burning buildings all while anyone else would be running away.

UPDATE:
Michelle Malkin and Glenn Reynolds both have major wrapups. The Anchoress remembers and offers up a prayer. Jammie will never forget nor forgive the Islamic terrorists who carried out the attacks. Sister Toldjah reposts her Project 2996 remembrance of Peter Edward Mardikian. My co-blogger Legalbgl has previously memorialized Donna Bernaerts-Kearns and Daniel Thomas Afflitto.

Others remembering 9/11: Ace, Lorie Byrd, Gateway Pundit, Macranger, AJ Strata, Don Surber, and Jules Crittenden.

UPDATE:
The New York Sun has a progress on the construction progress at Ground Zero. Much of what's contained in that report tracks the progress I've seen over the past year.

UPDATE:
Instapundit links. Thanks! I am updating this post throughout the day, and will report back later this afternoon on my impressions of the sights and sounds from around Ground Zero.

UPDATE:
Urban Infidel has done the thankless job of photographing the conspiracy freaks, the troofers, and the other protesters who flock to Ground Zero every year. Many thanks for doing what I was unable to do.

UPDATE:
Legalbgl has again offered up a memorial of another victim of the Islamic terror attacks on 9/11. He memorializes Alison Marie Wildman.

Thursday, August 28, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 48

Santiago Calatrava's vision for the transit hub at Ground Zero may be in jeopardy. He thinks that it can be built on time and on budget, but the Port Authority may scrap parts of the plan, including the vaulting spaces underground that would make construction of other portions of the Ground Zero project more daunting and technologically challenging.

The above-ground portion of the Calatrava hub would remain though.

The Port Authority is attempting to get the construction schedule under control and get the plaza ready for the 10th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, which is just over three years away. To accomplish that, the steel work below ground has to be completed by July of 2010.

UPDATE:
The NY Observer notes that Speaker Silver appears open to the idea of the Port Authority trimming around the edges of the transit hub to save money. Gee, thanks for speaking up Mr. Speaker. You've done such a great job of getting things done in your district. Oh, did I mention that Ground Zero is in your district? Yes, it is. Too bad you haven't exactly taken a strong interest in getting the site rebuilt sooner or demanding action on Fiterman Hall or the Deutsche Bank demolition. That's after the MTA announced that it was having trouble coming up with the money it needed to finish the Fulton Street transit hub.

Saturday, August 16, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 44

If the Port Authority can stick to its latest deadline, and it's anything but a sure thing, there's only 867 days left before the permanent PATH transit hub opens for business, along with the connector to the New York City subway system.

However, before that happens, we're going to have to put up with even bigger headaches. Vesey Street, which forms Ground Zero's northern border, will be closed to pedestrians so work can begin in earnest. However, that means that tens of thousands of people will have to be diverted around the block.

If you've ever seen this stretch of street during rush hour, it's wall to wall humanity pressing forward.

Construction is moving forward with elements of the Santiago Calatrava designed transit hub, as this video shows. Specifically, this is part of the East-West connector.

Meanwhile, the Port Authority is capping its contribution to the 9/11 memorial at $195 million. The 9/11 Memorial Foundation has to come up with the remaining $530 million, and their last official statement was that they had raised about $350 million, when they announced that Billy Crystal would be joining as a board member. There are reports that the project is expected to cost $1 billion, but the Foundation denies that there are budget issues. I'm skeptical of that given the cost issues with every other aspect of the project thus far.

Tuesday, July 01, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 37

The mess at Ground Zero takes center stage at the New York Post today, with wall to wall coverage of the disastrous management by the Port Authority. Steve Cuozzo notes that the Port Authority is busy trying to unload the Freedom Tower construction on some other company, potentially Related Cos. or Brookfield, but the report released yesterday by the Port Authority omits any mention of the Freedom Tower and that mess.

Cuozzo savages the Port Authority for its ongoing decision to try and get Calatrava's PATH station built according to Calatrava's wishes, which is pushing the memorial and other projects behind schedule and affecting everything due to the extraordinary costs.

The Post highlights the six people most responsible for the mess: Larry Silverstein, George Pataki, Anthony Shorris, Avi Schick, Charles Gargano, and Eliot Spitzer. I'd argue that Silverstein is least responsible among that bunch for the mess, since he's been at the mercy of the Port Authority's Shorris and the EDC and LMDC, run by Pataki's people Gargano and Schick. Spitzer did nothing to improve matters, and it looks like Governor Paterson is taking the first steps to impose order on the site. Charles Ward's report shows just how bad things are when he can't even come up with all of the parameters for just how off the rails the rebuilding has gone.

Here's just a sampling of the problems:
Ward said he had found the following issues that are critical to the overall project were still unresolved:

- Final design of the transportation hub and vehicle security center.

- Demolition of the former Deutsche Bank building.

- Accurate projection of rising construction costs, primarily caused by the country's oil crisis.

- Coordination of more than 100 contractors and subcontractors and 19 government agencies.

- Design and schedule for rebuilding the Cortlandt St. subway station.

Ward offered no new timetables or cost estimates in his review, which was prepared at Gov. Paterson's request.

He said he hoped to do so by September if these critical issues are addressed.
Of course, anyone who has read through my coverage of the rebuilding at Ground Zero would know that it's been an absolute battle. Cuozzo and Tom Toupisis at the Post have been reporting on this for years as well. It's not like it was a secret that the rebuilding was a mess and that the Port Authority and Lower Manhattan Development Corporation have botched the rebuilding.

The Deutsche Bank building debacle is a significant reason for ongoing delays since it is where the transportation hub and security screening facility is to be located, and it has yet to be demolished due to ongoing contamination concerns and the fact that remains were discovered at the building in 2006, forcing a renewed search throughout the area.

And for those who think that Donald Trump will come in and save things, you'd be sadly mistaken. There is not going to be some massive redesign of the site followed by the construction of the Twin Towers. That's simply not going to happen as the site is being prepared for the construction of the currently planned towers. Imposing a completely new design for rebuilding at Ground Zero would push back all the timetables even further, and delay rebuilding for years.

It's also funny listening to some of the political "leaders" complaining about the glacial pace of reconstruction and the candor of the Ward report. Where were these people when the rebuilding was lagging years ago and could prod the political leaders most responsible into action? That includes people like Jerrold Nadler, Charles Schumer, Sheldon Silver, and Scott Stringer. They were missing in action, and only now do we hear from them? Sad.

UPDATE:
The Calatrava designed transit hub has gone through yet another revision. No longer will the soaring winged roof open. An opening will remain, but it's far smaller than previous versions. Of course, those aspects of the design were what got people interested in the hub in the first place. Pretty soon, it will look no different than the completely utilitarian and bland temporary structure we have at present.

Thursday, May 08, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 30

The news relating to Ground Zero these days isn't exactly cheerful. The worst news is that the Star Ledger is reporting that 360 people who worked on the recovery efforts at Ground Zero and Fresh Kills landfill where materials from Ground Zero were taken after being excavated have died. Lawyers are trying to link those deaths to exposure at the site. People have been claiming that their ailments are due to exposure to Ground Zero air, and some of them may have a valid case, but the emotional pull and politicization of the situation makes it extremely difficult to separate the claims from the facts. Still, it's my hope that we do all that we can to keep the workers from being the American version of the Chernobyl liquidators.

Meanwhile, construction costs are continuing to chip away at the Santiago Calatrava PATH terminal. The architect and planners are trying to work within a cap of $2.5 billion for the project, and it's leading to compromises that may threaten the original vision for the plan.

At the same time, construction is progressing along the eastern portion of the site as excavations have progressed under the MTA's 1 line that was restored in 2002. That work is making it possible to advance construction and use every available inch of space within the site for development and related infrastructure.

Thursday, April 24, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 29

Public construction projects around the City are in shambles as the cash crunch hits home and the costs for construction materials continues to rise as demand for materials remains high worldwide.

There has been some grumbling at the Port Authority that the 9/11 Memorial project may get pushed back to 2011 or beyond. PA Chief Anthony Coscia has slammed those in charge of the WTC construction timetables for even suggesting that the project be delayed past the deadline in 2010.
"It has been brought to my attention, for instance, that staff is contemplating a further adjustment of the construction deadline for the memorial," Coscia continued in a letter that was also sent to PA board members. Insisting the construction go forward in as safe and secure a manner as possible, Coscia ruled out any extensions of the current deadline of 2010 for completing the Memorial Plaza.

"The board of commissioners committed to these deadlines because we recognized the critical need to accelerate redevelopment of the WTC site," Coscia wrote.
Here's the thing. One of the reasons why costs are skyrocketing for all the projects at Ground Zero is that all the delays are catching up with the costs - each delay means that material costs continue to rise and there's no hedge in place against the rises.

Some are still calling for the Calatrava PATH station to be junked, even though the above ground portion of the facility is actually at costs - it's the underground facilities that are driving up the cost for the facility that handles 50,000 commuters daily. The MTA has completely screwed up its capital plan, and commuters around the City really don't have any faith in MTA numbers or projections, to say nothing of when those projects underway will actually be completed.

Elsewhere, while Hudson Street got a boost from Saatchi and Saatchi remaining at 375 Hudson Street in a long term deal, Thomson Reuters is going to be moving Thomson staff from 395 Hudson to 195 Broadway - within sneezing distance of Ground Zero by the end of the year.

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 28

Even as construction continues in and around Ground Zero, there are ominous signs on the horizon that the Santiago Calatrava designed PATH transit hub is about to meet its doom because costs continue rising precipitously.
The head of the federal agency paying to build a transit hub at the World Trade Center site said Wednesday the project now costs about $3 billion, more than $500 million over its latest budget.

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which owns the site, has sought for more than a year to cut costs for the winged-dome design for a PATH commuter rail hub at ground zero. Officials said in early 2007 that Spanish architect Santiago Calatrava's design for the lower Manhattan hub would be modified but they have never released a new design. Construction began in 2005.

The project is primarily funded by a $1.9 billion grant from the Federal Transit Administration, which supports locally planned and operated mass transit systems. A consultant's report for the agency earlier this year concluded that the project as designed has almost no chance of being built for its $2.2 billion budget.

FTA Administrator James Simpson said Wednesday that based on the project's current budget documents, "if the project is as advertised as today, it's in the $3 billion range."
Throw in the fact that Governor Paterson is going to have something to say about choosing the replacement for Port Authority Executive Director Anthony Shorris, and we might as well get back to calling this feature on A Blog For All, The Battle For Ground Zero.

It appears that Shorris was ousted because he was favoring New Jerseyeans over New Yorkers for top positions within the bistate agency.

Newsday
thinks that this is the time to push ahead and reset priorities at Ground Zero with the appointment of a new head honcho. Pushing ahead is a fine idea, and getting the memorial built is also most crucial, but so is ensuring that infrastructure is built that meets not only current needs, but the needs for Lower Manhattan for decades to come. And it's not like the memorial hasn't faced cash crunches either. Newsday seems to forget that the budget spiraled out of control before hard caps were made on what would be spent and tough decisions made on how to keep within a set budget. I have my doubts that they'll still make their budget, even with the $350 million in private funds raised thus far.

There's also talk floating around that the City and State may try to shift money from Ground Zero to the floundering Moynihan Station project, but I doubt that will pass muster with the feds, who made the money contingent on getting the PATH transit station built and not for projects in Midtown.

Friday, April 18, 2008

The Rebuilding of Ground Zero, Part 27

On the heels of reports indicating that workers had to remove several tons worth of deficient concrete from the work done thus far at the Freedom Tower comes a report in the Post that confidential schematics were found tossed in a garbage bin near Ground Zero.
Two sets of confidential blueprints for the planned Freedom Tower, which is set to rise at Ground Zero, were carelessly dumped in a city garbage can on the corner of West Houston and Sullivan streets, The Post has learned.

Experts said the detailed, floor-by-floor schematics contain enough detail for terrorists to plot a devastating attack.

"Secure Document - Confidential," warns the title page on each of the two copies of the 150-page schematic that a homeless, recovering drug addict discovered in the public trash can.

"Any time a sensitive document is unintentionally left behind, it's a treasure trove for a potential adversary," aid Robert Strang, CEO of Investigative Management Group, a global security firm. "It enables them to look for vulnerabilities in design that they can target - an age-old military tactic."

Informed of what the homeless man, Mike Fleming, had found, shocked Port Authority officials called it an egregious security lapse.

"Violating these protocols is cause for serious disciplinary action - up to termination for employees and breach of contract and legal action for contractors," said Candace McAdams, PA director of media relations.
Meanwhile, inspections of cranes around the City revealed problems with one at the Goldman Sachs building across from Ground Zero. That crane remains closed with a stop-work order after inspectors found that the ties to the building weren't done according to the plans.

It also appears that the Santiago Calatrava designed transit hub will not be ready by the 2013 date.

While the economic slowdown and problems with major projects, including Ground Zero, the West Side Hudson Yards and Atlantic Yards get the headlines, other projects around the city are moving forward, and the construction business remains pretty strong this year and next, with a projected $25 billion to be underway in each of the next two years.

UPDATE:
A series of photos showing the state of things around Ground Zero, including the construction of the bathtub, excavations for Tower 2 and 3, and the Freedom Tower foundation work.